Case study

2025

Timm Chiusano

A creator with 1.7M+ followers asked for someone to look at his data scientifically. We pulled six years across TikTok, Instagram and YouTube. After the audit, he added 328,000+ Instagram followers at a 6.7% Reels interaction rate.

Timm Chiusano

+328K

New Instagram followers after the audit

6.7%

Reels interaction rate

6 years

Of cross-platform data analyzed

CREATOR

Creator, 1.7M+ followers

CHANNELS

TikTok, Instagram, YouTube

AUDIENCE

1.7M+ followers

ENGAGEMENT

Audit + ongoing reporting

YEAR

2025

The problem

In-platform metrics don’t tell the full story. For creators, watching them in real time is misleading at best and demoralizing at worst.

Timm came to us through a public Instagram Story: “I despise looking at my own metrics, but I’m very coachable… I’d do this myself but I need someone to help me look at things scientifically.” He had 1.7M+ followers across three platforms and felt his TikTok performance slipping. What he needed was someone to read the data without the emotional weight of being the creator behind it.

We looked at the platforms first

Most creator audits only look at the individual. We started with the platforms.

When we pulled six years of data across TikTok, Instagram and YouTube, the slowdown Timm was feeling on TikTok had a clear explanation. The platform grew 35.8% in 2021 and 22.2% in 2022, then just 4% by 2024. His peak ran exactly with the platform’s peak. He wasn’t doing anything wrong, and understanding that changed every strategic conversation that followed.

TikTok platform growth fell from 35.8% in 2021 to 22.2% in 2022 and 4% in 2024

Going deeper

We looked at like rate, share rate, comment rate, publishing volume and follower growth, month by month. The deeper read on TikTok turned up a second finding: like rates had softened, but share rates had increased across every video length in 2025. People were engaging more. The platform was just reaching fewer of them.

The third finding was audience. The same creator had three meaningfully different audiences. TikTok skews younger, with 30% aged 18–24, and leans toward entertainment. YouTube is mostly men aged 25–44, focused on career and personal growth. Instagram sits between the two, slightly older than TikTok and invested in Timm’s full story. Each needed a different approach, and that’s now built into how we plan his content across channels.

Timm's audience by platform: TikTok skews 18 to 24, Instagram sits in between, YouTube is mostly men 25 to 44

What we focused on

01

Context before tactics

We read the platform's trends before judging Timm's. A slowdown that hits everyone on TikTok isn't a content problem, so we didn't treat it like one.

02

Signal over vanity

We weighted share and save rates over likes. Instagram's Adam Mosseri has said those are the signals the algorithm weighs most.

03

Built around him

Reporting shaped around what Timm needs to act on, so he gets the read without having to watch his own metrics.

If you’re a creator, founder, or brand trying to make smarter decisions, not just louder ones, I can’t recommend this kind of outside-in analysis enough.

Timm Chiusano

Timm Chiusano

Creator, 1.7M+ followers

Want this kind of read on your data?

Book a call and we’ll talk through what your numbers could be telling you.